The embattled former Greenpoint metal venue Saint Vitus Bar was met with raucous fanfare this month when the opening of its highly-anticipated new outpost was announced on one of Bushwick’s busiest nightlife corridors.
But locals say they’ve been raising concerns for months over the bar’s alleged refusal to compromise on late-night operating hours ahead of its fall opening, and are already overwhelmed by a post-pandemic surge of bars and music venues—with patrons turning residential streets into a nightlife playground and leaving a growing trail of garbage, puke, urine and obnoxious noise behind.
“Residents fear another 4 a.m. music venue will, quote, ‘ruin their lives,’ and deepen oversaturation,” Kristine Malden, Brooklyn Community Board 4’s permits and licenses chairperson, said at a recent meeting.
“It’s pretty serious over there.”
St. Vitus’ new location, slated for a 496-person capacity live-music venue, bar, courtyard and café at 428 and 430 Troutman St.—the former site of the Brooklyn Made concert hall—would be open noon to 4 a.m., seven days a week, according to a since-rejected liquor license application submitted to the community board earlier this year (the bar secured a temporary liquor license from the State Liquor Authority last week, but a permanent license hearing before the SLA has yet to be scheduled).
“We spent quite a bit of time on this one,” Malden recalled. “It’s between Wyckoff and St. Nicholas [Avenues] in a really saturated area: there’s something like 30-plus other liquor licenses right around there within 500 feet.”
“Quite a few” residents living on the Starr/Troutman Street block sandwiched by Brooklyn Made and Xanadu Roller Arts (262 Starr St.) testified at a committee meeting in May about issues regarding “how difficult it’s been living” with late-night noise on the block since both spots opened in 2021 and 2024, respectively.
One neighbor claimed they’ve since resorted to sleeping in a different neighborhood on weekends to avoid the booming bass from Xanadu, according to meeting documents.
In the board’s rejection of St. Vitus’ application, they said the club’s operators declined to adopt a consistent hours policy—which includes closing outdoor spaces by 10 p.m., no alcohol sales past midnight on Sundays, and reduced late-night hours on weekdays—and noted “serious community testimony on noise and saturation.”
Multiple requests for comment were not returned by Saint Vitus, famously shut down after 13 years in Greenpoint in the middle of a hardcore show in 2024.
In their application documents, reps from the bar contend the venue space is already soundproofed, and outdoor queuing and courtyard areas are enclosed by walls to further prevent any noise pollution.
“Litter on adjacent sidewalks attributable to the venue’s patrons will be collected as part of post-event cleanup,” the owners vowed.
But sources on the board said Saint Vitus Bar and Xanadu are part of a larger, growing concern surrounding noise, trash and belligerent partygoers funneled into the neighborhood every weekend with little accountability from new businesses.
“We’re tired, and the community is tired,” longtime CB4 chairperson Robert Camacho told me. “[Residents] can’t sleep … When you get up in the morning, it’s like a third-world country—garbage all over the place.
“Go over to Troutman on a Saturday or Friday night, and see people crying with babies trying to go to sleep,” he added. “Some people work from home, and can’t sleep because you got idiots outside drinking, smoking, and partying, all because the owner wants to make more money.”
Camacho said Saint Vitus ultimately refused to scale back its proposed hours, and argued the business can’t be profitable without operating late into the night—well beyond the board’s recommended closing hours of midnight on weekdays and 2 a.m. on weekends.
Noise complaints stemming from clubs, bars and restaurants have more than doubled from 508 filed in 2019 to more than 1,130 in 2025, according to city records.
In 2025 alone, litter complaints in the district jumped 26% compared to the year prior. The district has become so walloped by weekend trash that the area’s city council member Jennifer Gutiérrez introduced a bill earlier this month to provide more waste removal services to designated nightlife districts, which would include Bushwick.
“For New Yorkers who live in lively districts like mine, the cost of someone’s fun night out can unjustly impact the cleanliness of the entire neighborhood,” Gutiérrez said in a statement.
“Through a community-oriented approach, this bill aims to rectify long-standing concerns that have gone unaddressed throughout the city.”
Board members said the number of liquor license applications on the rowdy strip don’t appear to be slowing down anytime soon—but larger event venues, like Brooklyn Made, Xanadu and even the new 8,000-person open-air hall Pacha (140 Stewart Ave.) nearby, have marked a turning point in drawing larger crowds, noise and trash that they say existing infrastructure simply can’t keep up with.
District Manager Celeste Leon said the initial Bushwick nightlife boom on Wyckoff Avenue, led by House of Yes (2 Wyckoff Ave.) and Lot 45 (411 Troutman St.) in the mid-2010s, saw owners attending community board meetings and addressing issues in “real-time.”
“But when folks like Brooklyn Made came in, I think that’s when things really shifted: having a music venue in addition to nightclubs,” she said.
Ten years later, “I think people expect [it’s like] when they go to Cancún,” Leon quipped, “but when you’re in the middle of Bushwick, you’re trying to go home, and all of a sudden you have like five different nightclubs or big venues and all of this foot traffic—all of these people eating, drinking, partying… I think we’ve reached our point.
“Like, how is this within the public’s interest?”
One key to addressing the unmitigated nightlife boom could lie in the enforcement of liquor license rules, according to Assemblymember Maritza Davila, who blamed the State Liquor Authority for issuing an overabundance of liquor licenses—against its own rules—at a May 20 board meeting.
More than three on-premises liquor licenses within 500 feet of each other are typically not allowed under the state’s 500 Foot Law—but in some areas of Bushwick, there are some blocks with 35 or more, Malden said.
On St. Vitus’ new block, there are 32 liquor licensees within 500 feet of each other, with six additional pending applications, according to state records. Among those are for a bar called The Museum (1329 Willoughby Ave.), the Korean eatery Sura (31 Wyckoff Ave.), and the upcoming “theatre, cultural and nightlife destination” dubbed The Empyrean Club (421 Troutman St.).
Last May alone, the community board reviewed more than a half-dozen liquor licenses, including ones for an “art-first bar” at 1196 Myrtle Ave., Esquina Del Sabor (446 Wilson Ave.), Danger Danger (232 Knickerbocker Ave.), Fun Ramen House (313 Knickerbocker Ave.) and Diego’s Gyros (178 Irving Ave.), the last of which told the board it needed a liquor license to “stay competitive with the nightlife in the neighborhood,” per Malden.
“It’s getting out of control,” Davila fumed at the meeting, “but we are working on it.
“They were giving out licenses like crazy, and we were trying to stay ahead of it. Unfortunately that didn’t happen,” she said. “I’m so discouraged and disgusted with what’s going on, but it takes a community to put a stop to these types of things.”
“You just can’t have liquor and weed spots … in one little area,” Camacho sighed, noting he would like to see more diversity in new businesses in the district in the future.
“We want to have a shoe store, a sneaker store, a hair stylist, an art and culture community thing, or maybe a swimming pool,” he said.
“We need to have that: You just can’t have liquor, liquor, liquor.”
Nicole Rosenthal is a Brooklyn-based investigative reporter. You can reach them at Nicole.rosenthal1@gmail.com, @bynrosenthal on X or @nrosenthal.03 on Signal.
Leave a Reply