Another Italian restaurant is rumored to be coming to Ridgewood and, this time, it’s replacing a different, recently departed Italian joint.
Velma (5-84 Seneca Ave.) quietly closed last December, shortly after opening in early 2023. Owners JR Savage and Paulina Loyo-Grigonis still run their more popular, Mexican-centric Gordo’s Cantina (140 St. Nicholas Ave.), which opened in Bushwick in late 2019.
On Velma’s closure, Loyo-Grigonis told me, “Velma closed down because ownership no longer wanted to operate and financially support it.”
It was a way out to better focus on Gordo’s: “We were always on good terms with our landlord and he allowed us to forfeit the lease and the space to cure some outstanding debt on the lease.”

Per what a bartender at The Seneca (5-82 Seneca Ave.) tells us, the new Monti’s Tavern will be an Italian restaurant. The cosmic pasta scales will soon be rebalanced.
An opening date couldn’t be confirmed beyond the rumor that Monti’s Tavern would begin service “by the end of the summer.”
Craig Montalbano, listed as the principal on a June liquor license filing that confirms the Monti’s Tavern moniker, previously developed the Scarlet (371 Stockholm St.), an eight-story apartment building off the DeKalb L.
According to deed records in ACRIS, Seneca Plaza LLC, also tied to Montalbano, purchased 5-84 Seneca, along with the neighboring 5-76 and 5-82 lots, in May 2025. Montalbano could not be reached to confirm details of his upcoming restaurant opening.
The transition from Velma’s to Monti’s should be a smooth one. Per Loyo-Grigonis, “Since we had done some substantial work to make the space a full service restaurant, he saw an opportunity to input his own concept there. We were happy to serve our customers and be part of the neighborhood, and we wish him all the best with this new endeavor.”
Monti’s will join buzzy Il Gigante (8-80 Woodward Ave.) and the more rustic Joe’s (66-11 Forest Ave.), among other Italian joints.




Leave a Reply