All hope has gone to the dogs.
Rumors that dog owners in Bed-Stuy might soon return to their beloved Herbert Von King Park dog run back before the end of the decade have been dashed. After potentially contaminated soil was discovered, we can confirm that city officials already dismissed a community solution floated by local volunteers as pure dogma.
Volunteers who help operate the run initially floated the possibility of covering the entire run with asphalt or concrete, an interim fix reportedly considered by the Parks Department, per a Nov. 7 post from the HVKDogRun Instagram account.
“We know this is not the solution we were hoping for but at this time no other temporary fencing in the park can replace the area that was lost,” read the post. The rumor was then picked up by neighborhood newsletter Bed-Stuy Stoop.
“Parks briefly considered the possibility of adding a layer of asphalt, but we determined it was not desirable and do not have any plans to do so,” a Parks spokesperson said in a statement Tuesday.
The news comes after the popular dog park was shut down last August, when routine testing found potential soil contamination including elevated levels of arsenic and mercury, Brooklyn Paper reported.
“More significant” contamination was found three to six inches below the ground surface, Parks said at the time.
The testing was done as part of a reconstruction of the dog run, which was set to break ground in 2027.

The makeshift pavement would’ve served as a barrier between dogs and soil found to contain elevated levels of toxic metals, but Parks said it ruled out that option in its early stages.
The project, estimated at between $1 and $3 million through a mix of mayoral, City Council and funding from the Brooklyn Borough President’s office, would take at least two years to complete, according to the city’s project website.
Even without Parks’ final kibosh on the pet project, some locals blasted the use of asphalt at the dog run. They claimed it would exacerbate the effects of brutally hot temperatures in the summer, increase flood risks and cause physical issues for some dogs.
“Really worried about blistering hot temps in the summer and terrible ice in the winter leading to frozen paws and dog/human falls. Seems extremely unsafe to me,” one user wrote, adding with a green, repulsed emoji (“🤢”).
“Also, the smell in the summer of hundreds of dogs[’] pee on hot concrete,” they warned.

Until a new dog run is built under the reconstruction plan, the city has opened off-leash courtesy hours in the park, running before 9 a.m. and after 9 p.m.
Dog run regular Scarlett, who runs the HVKDogRun Instagram account, said the off-leash hours addition has been “helpful,” though she hasn’t heard any update about the asphalt plan from the Parks department since it was floated.
“The loss of the dog run for an unforeseeable future with no communication from Parks has been frustrating,” Scarlett told me.
“The Parks department has been very adamant that they’re not gonna be putting in temporary dog runs anywhere else in the park, so we don’t really know at this time what the future looks like,” she said, adding that off-leash hours have been helpful, but worrisome for some dog owners, given the amount of vehicular traffic on busy roads like Marcy and Lafayette avenues.
“We wish people would understand it’s like having a tiny toddler at home… and taking recess away from them,” she said.
“For many of us community members, it was a way to connect daily and get out of the house and socialize ourselves.”
Nicole Rosenthal is a Brooklyn-based investigative reporter. You can reach them at nicole.rosenthal1@gmail.com, @bynrosenthalon X or @nrosenthal.03 on Signal.
Photos by Andrew Karpan.



Leave a Reply