Panic spread briefly along Knickerbocker Avenue when contractors at Ayat in Bushwick (242 Knickerbocker Ave.) were spotted stripping the restaurant’s flooring one night last week.
Fortunately, for fans of Abdul Elenani’s ever-expanding chain of Palestinian fare, city documents showed it was only a $75,000 interior renovation—but it wasn’t the only recent expense that the business has forked over in recent months.
Back in July, Elenani, who runs Ayat with his wife and brand namesake Ayat Masoud, agreed to pay $90,000 to settle a lawsuit from Avila Jimenez and Senon Martinez Montoya, a pair of former employees at the chain’s location in Industry City.
Jimenez, a server there, said he was paid wages as low as $10 an hour. Montoya, a prep cook, said he was paid wages as low as $12 an hour. Both said they saw their tips pooled and then distributed instead to the restaurant’s managers, including back to Elenani, in violation of labor laws.
Despite operating a chain of seven restaurants around the city, including the Bushwick location since 2024, the lawsuit says that the chain’s employees were never paid overtime, and their managers never used “any time tracking device, such as sign-in sheets or punch cards, that accurately reflected their actual hours worked.”
It’s not the first time Elenani has been accused of shirking his employees, or his legal responsibilities as an employer. A trio of servers sued Elenani and Ayat in 2022 in state court; one of them, who had been a manager, said she was “promised wages of $10,000 per month. However, [Elenani] never paid her the full amount, claiming that they could not afford to pay her the full agreed-upon wages.”
In 2024, his business was fined $5,000 for failing to carry workers’ compensation insurance. His first Bay Ridge location, which the Times profiled for its value as a culture war flashpoint, was briefly shut down by the Health Department for issues like roaches, evidence of mice, and flies.
Nevertheless, Elenani has persisted. Last month, Ayat announced it was almost ready to open its eighth location, its first in Philadelphia, after quietly closing his venture into Staten Island, at one point a campaign stop for then-candidate Zohran Mamdani. “We enjoyed being in Staten Island while it lasted,” Elenani told the Staten Island Advance, without explaining further.
Elenani was a vocal supporter of Mamdani’s election campaign, with his location in Bushwick both offering free food to canvassers and, most memorably, hosting a free dinner to celebrate Mamdani’s win in last June’s Democratic primary. Over 4,000 people showed up, Elenani later told the London website Middle East Eye. He told the site that the weight of his generosity was so great that it forced him to “shut down every restaurant kitchen in the city to focus on delivering food via Uber to Bushwick.” Per the Times, Elenani’s restaurants also donate some money to Palestinian humanitarian relief groups, “though he doesn’t set a specific percentage.”
In court, Elenani responded to his former employees’ latest claims by lawyering up. Litigation stretched for about eight months or so. Both sides debated vigorously, largely over whether or not one of the various shell companies that Elenani allegedly used to manage the chain (a certain Ayat LLC) was, in some legal way, “a nonexistent entity,” and whether it should be cited in the case at all. Finally, in July, lawyers from both sides announced they had privately reached a deal. The lawsuit was over.
“After multiple rounds of offers and counteroffers over the ensuing months, the parties agreed to the following settlement arrangement: defendants shall pay a total of $90,000.00 in monthly installments, with the final payment due by December 12, 2026,” read the deal.
Lawyers from either side did not respond to a request for comment on whether the chain’s labor practices have changed from what Jimenez and Montoya claimed.
Reached for comment on the latest lawsuit, a representative of Ayat’s management team wrote “thats [sic] old news brother,” adding a “🙏” emoji.
“False allegations and closed out,” they wrote.
The lawyers for the employees had asked for $172,601.96, before settling for a little more than half that. After paying their lawyers, the two former Ayat employees would be left with $59,566.40, or $29,783.20 for each of them.
Top photo by Andrew Karpan.



Leave a Reply